Museum Map
Anti-Germanism
Clay County Historical Soc.

 Anti-Germanism In Minnesota Article

National

Minnesota

Clay County

Works Cited

Not all Americans were enthusiastic about the United States’ entrance into the war so President Wilson tried to promote organizations and spread propaganda in support of the war. However, Minnesota or at least some of its citizens needed no encouragement from the President. 

Information about the Commission, including its powers, and duties:

  • The Minnesota Commission of Public Safety was created a few days after the United States declared war on Germany.

  • It was the first such state agency in the country and it last until the end of December in 1918.

  • It was a seven-person interim agency designed to take action “toward suppressing disloyal outbreaks and possible disturbances of order in communities where the German element was predominant.”

  • Given the power to execute “all act and things necessary or proper so that the military, civil and industrial resources of the state maybe most efficiently applied toward maintenance of the state and nation, and toward the successful prosecution of such war.”

The Minnesota Commission of Public Safety was given nearly unlimited powers.

  • Ability to seize and condemn property

  • Ability to require people to stand before it or any of its representatives

  • Ability to make district courts issue subpoenas

  • It could observe public officials and their behavior

  • Finally, it had the muscle to advise the governor of what actions should be taken against offending officials.

Many people believed then and now that these powers (and others) were unconstitutional in practice. The Commission stuck its fingers into many areas and issued over 59 specific orders dealing with war-related topics such as food production, iron-ore output, the welfare of soldiers, conservation, and even the cost of milk. The Commission of Public Safety even had its own army to fight off German sympathizers.

However, it's the the Commission’s foray in education that we want to focus on. 

  • The Commission focused on the use of the German language in school because it was the actual language rather than the ethnic identity that gave rise to mistrust. A goal of the Commission of Public Safety was to form “One country, One Flag, and One Speech.”

  •   The Commission felt it had a right to fear Germanism, because one-quarter of the two million people living in Minnesota during this time were either German born or of German-Austrian descent and because German was the most widely used non-English language in Minnesota schools. 

  •  By September 12, 1917 the Commission had recommended the creation of an eight-person committee to study the teaching of German in public schools, and in particular the textbooks used to teach the language. 

  • The Commission received information from 350 sources about the various textbooks in use. The committee then probed the textbooks trying to figure out if the books were at all “prejudicial to the interests of the United States, or contrary to those ideals of democracy which every liberty-loving nation wished to inculcate in the hearts of the young.”

The Commission used five categories to evaluate the German language books:

  • Any pictures of the military, the royal family, or its insignia 

  • Literature that uses the “might makes right” philosophy 

  • German propaganda or anything that could be perceived as such

  • Literary works that demonstrate an appreciation for the German lifestyle

  • Any German patriotic poems

If the books violated any of these categories the Minnesota Committee on Public Safety recommended that it be removed from use in the school curriculum. 

Click next to read more about Anti-Germanism in Minnesota

Next

 

 

About the Museum
Contact
Partnership